If you’re buying a new range or cooktop, you might be deciding between electric or induction. Induction cooking is currently one of the top choices. It has risen to popularity because of how fast food cooks through the induction method. While both use electricity to cook food and produce the same outcome, the way they get there is quite different. Both are great options, but it’s important to understand the differences between them and which will be the best fit for your cooking needs.
Standard electric cooking sends electric current to open coils or radiant burner elements below the glass or ceramic surface to transfer heat to cooking vessels (pots or pans) and then to the food inside. This process is known as thermal conduction. It takes time for the burner to heat and transfer heat to the vessel as well as to cool down due to the residual heat that the burners hold; after reducing the temperature, burners take a few minutes to settle to a lower setting and remain hot after burners are turned off.
An induction cooktop or range looks similar to a glass-top electric counterpart but is powered by an electromagnetic field below the surface of the glass cooktop. Instead of passing heat along from surface to cookware to food, induction cooktops heat the cookware directly resulting in even cooking and less loss of energy. The magnetic field reacts with the cookware (which must contain ferrous iron) and transfers heat and energy directly into the cooking vessel. Only the pan, and what’s directly under it, on an induction range gets hot. The surface around it stays cool.
WHAT ARE THE ADVANTAGES OF INDUCTION COOKING?
- Cooking is faster. In general, an induction range or cooktop is 2-4 minutes faster than gas or electric at bringing 6 quarts of water to a boil.
- Excellent temperature control. Allows for precise temperature adjustments and reduces the chance of burning food. When you turn the burner off, heat transfer stops immediately, so there’s less of a chance of foods boiling over or overcooking.
- Easy clean up. Spatters or spills outside of the pan will not bake onto the cooking surface. There are no burners to take apart and reassemble.
- More energy efficient. An induction model uses 10% less energy than a smooth-top electric range.
- Safe. There is no emission of gas into the air. Cloth objects will not catch on fire because no element is exposed and heat only transfers to items with iron particles in it. Induction units also turn off when the cookware is removed from the heating element so there’s little risk of accidentally leaving it on when cooking is done. Burners accidentally turned on will not get hot. Fire hazards and risk of burns is reduced.
Electrical appliances such as an induction unit create Non-Ionizing or Low-Frequency EMF. According to the National Cancer Institute there are no current studies that have been able to provide a link that Non-Ionizing radiation causes any adverse health issues such as cancer. In fact the natural radiation emitted from the sun is far more harmful than induction unit could ever be.
The American Heart Association has also deemed the low electromagnetic field safe for patients with pacemakers or medical implants.
- Reduces kitchen heat and ventilation requirements.
WHAT ARE THE DISADVANTAGES OF INDUCTION COOKING?
- Cost. Induction surfaces are an investment since the technology is relatively new. However, as induction becomes more mainstream, the cost is decreasing.
- Require cookware containing ferrous iron. Specifically, that means stainless steel, cast iron, and carbon steel. Pots and pans made from aluminum and copper aren’t compatible. Most confusing of all, some cookware uses a combination of materials in its construction, so its induction status isn’t always obvious. Look for pots and pans marked “induction safe” or “induction compatible.” An easy test to see if cookware is compatible is to see if a magnet strongly sticks to the bottom of the pan. If a magnet sticks to the bottom, it can be used with induction.
- Caution – Cooktops can get hot. Heat is transferred from the cooking vessel to the glass through conduction, much as a hot pan would transfer heat to a countertop if you set it down to rest. The glass surface never gets as hot as it would on a traditional radiant electric range but one can never assume that it will be cool to the touch.
- Unfamiliar sounds. Some consumers report a buzz or hum on the higher settings resulting from the high energy transferring from the coil to the pan. There is also the possibility of hearing the element clicking or the fan cooling the electronics. All are common and resolve by turning down the heat or adding food to the pot or pan,, Consumer Reports says that heavy, flat-bottomed pans help reduce the vibrations that cause the buzz.
- Magnetic field can interfere with digital thermometers. Consumer Reports suggests the need to resort to an analog thermometer—an old-fashioned solution to a modern problem.
- Requires a learning curve. Induction cooking takes some getting used to. Some nuances include: placing the right sized cookware in the center of the heating element in order for it to be properly activated; cookware must be flat-bottomed; the heating element may cut off prematurely or shut off without warning when the pan is shaken or moved; food may overcook until one learns that cookware doesn’t take long to preheat and a lower heat setting is needed to maintain the temperature of food. Touch pad controls also take time to get used to.
- Cooktops scratch easily. Although induction cooktops are made of a durable glass-ceramic composite, they are more prone to scratching if scratchy pans are slid across the surface and even cracking if a heavy pot is set down too hard. Most manufacturers suggest using cookware with clean, smooth bottoms, and to avoid sliding pots and pans across the surface. Sharp tools or abrasive cleaning materials should not be used on the surface.
- Repairs may be expensive after the warranty period.
- A 240V outlet is required. An induction range or cooktop easily replaces an electric range or cooktop. If the conversion is from gas, an electrician will need to install the proper wiring.
- Requires canners (pressure and water) specifically made for induction cooktops. Both are available.
While induction cooking is one of the most efficient, safest and precise ways to prepare food, the question remains, is it for you?